Teaching Children To Think Critically (Without A Programme)

JLTP Introductory Video by Dr John Langrehr

Loading...
You got lucky! We have no ad to show to you!
Advertisement

Thinking-skills programmes are sold to Singapore parents constantly, usually on the promise that critical thinking is a transferable skill that can be installed in a course of lessons.

The evidence for that promise is weak.

Programmes that teach “thinking” in the abstract reliably make children better at the exercises in the programme. What they’ve consistently struggled to show is far transfer: the skill turning up in a different subject, months later, unprompted.

Thinking well isn’t a free-floating ability. It runs on knowledge: you reason well about things you know a lot about. Which is good news, because it means the work happens in ordinary conversation instead of in a paid course.

The questions to ask

Almost all of this is in how you respond when a child says something.

  • “How do you know?” The single most valuable question in the language. Ask it about good answers as well as wrong ones, so it doesn’t read as a challenge.
  • “What makes you say that?” Gets the reasoning, not the conclusion.
  • “What else could explain it?” The core move of critical thinking: more than one possible answer.
  • “How could we find out?” Converts an argument into an investigation.
  • “What would change your mind?” A hard question, and a good one from about eight.
  • “Who might disagree, and why?” Perspective-taking, which is most of good reasoning.

Two habits that help more than the questions

Wait after asking. Adults typically allow about a second of silence before filling it. Count to five instead. Thinking is slow and the silence is the thinking. Most children answer if you simply don’t rescue them.

Loading...
You got lucky! We have no ad to show to you!
Advertisement

Don’t answer their questions immediately. “That’s a good question: what do you think?” first, every time. Then answer properly. A child whose questions are always instantly resolved learns that thinking is something other people do.

Let them be wrong

  • Don’t correct straight away. “Let’s test it” beats “no, it’s this”. A child who works out their own error learns something a correction can’t supply.
  • Let them argue with you, and change your mind sometimes, visibly, saying so. “You’ve convinced me, I hadn’t thought of that.” This teaches more about reasoning than any exercise.
  • Model being wrong. “I was sure about that and I was wrong.” Children who’ve never seen an adult update assume that being wrong is a failure of character.
  • Distinguish fact, opinion and guess explicitly, and often. “Is that something you know, or something you think?”
  • Resist rewarding speed. School rewards fast right answers; thinking is slower than that. “Take your time” is a good thing to say at home.

Thinking critically about what they see online

Your child will encounter more claims online before they’re twelve than you did before you were thirty, and an increasing share is generated, not reported. Four questions, taught early enough to become automatic:

  1. Who made this, and why? Someone made it, and they wanted something.
  2. How would they know? Were they there? Are they qualified? Are they selling something?
  3. What’s missing? What would the other side say?
  4. Could this have been made by a machine? Images, voices and video can now be generated convincingly, and “I saw it” is no longer evidence.

Practise on real things. An advertisement aimed at them, a viral video a friend forwarded, a headline. Doing it together on something they care about works far better than a lesson about media literacy.

Everyday things that build it

  • Cooking. Prediction, measurement, adjustment, and immediate feedback on whether the reasoning was right.
  • Board games with real decisions, the ones where you weigh options rather than roll and move.
  • Fixing something broken together, out loud: what could be wrong, how do we check.
  • Reading widely. This is the knowledge base that reasoning runs on, and it’s the highest-value item here.
  • Open-ended building: blocks, Lego without instructions, cardboard.
  • Boredom. A child with nothing to do generates their own problems to solve. A fully scheduled week removes this entirely.
  • Real decisions with real consequences. Spending their own money is the fastest teacher of trade-offs there is.

If you’re considering a programme

  • Ask for independent published evidence, not testimonials or internal data.
  • Ask specifically about transfer: does the skill show up elsewhere, months later? That’s the whole claim.
  • Sit in on a normal class, not a demonstration.
  • Check what it displaces. An hour of programme instead of an hour of free play or reading is a trade, not an addition.
  • If your child enjoys it, that’s a legitimate reason to go. Just buy it for that, and not for the promise about transferable thinking.

Frequently asked questions

Can critical thinking be taught as a standalone skill?

Only weakly. Programmes teaching thinking in the abstract make children better at the programme’s own exercises, but consistently struggle to show far transfer: the skill appearing in a different subject, months later, unprompted. Reasoning runs on knowledge, and people think well about things they know a lot about.

Loading...
You got lucky! We have no ad to show to you!
Advertisement

How do I teach my child to think critically?

Mostly through how you respond. “How do you know?”, “what makes you say that?”, “what else could explain it?” and “how could we find out?” do most of the work. Two habits do more than the questions: wait five seconds instead of one after asking, and answer their questions with “what do you think?” before answering properly.

Should I correct my child when they’re wrong?

Not immediately. “Let’s test it” teaches more than “no, it’s this”, because a child who finds their own error gains something a correction can’t give. Let them argue with you, and change your mind out loud when they make a good point.

How do I teach media literacy?

Four questions, practised until automatic: who made this and why, how would they know, what’s missing, and could this have been made by a machine. Practise on real things like an advert aimed at them or a video a friend forwarded, instead of as a lesson.

Loading...
You got lucky! We have no ad to show to you!
Advertisement

Are thinking-skills enrichment programmes worth it?

Ask for independent published evidence, not testimonials. Ask specifically about transfer, since that’s the entire claim, and sit in on a normal class. Then check what the hour displaces: free play and reading do more for reasoning than most programmes. If your child enjoys it, that’s a fine reason to go; just buy it for that.

What everyday activities build reasoning?

Cooking, board games with real decisions, fixing broken things out loud, open-ended building, reading widely, and boredom: a child with nothing to do invents problems to solve, which a fully scheduled week removes.

What to remember

Critical thinking isn’t installed by a course. It grows out of knowledge and out of how you respond when your child says something.

Ask “how do you know?” and then wait five seconds. Answer their questions with “what do you think?” first. Let them be wrong, and let them change your mind out loud.

Teach the four questions for anything online, including whether a machine made it. And leave enough unscheduled time for them to get bored.

Read next

Loading...
You got lucky! We have no ad to show to you!
Advertisement

Written by

Roshni Mahtani