TAP top app download banner
theAsianparent
theAsianparent
Product Guide
  • Together Against RSV
  • SG60
  • Pregnancy
  • Parenting
  • Child
  • Feeding & Nutrition
  • Education
  • Lifestyle
  • Events
  • Holiday Hub
  • Aptamil
  • TAP Recommends
  • Shopping
  • Press Releases
  • Project Sidekicks
  • Community
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us
  • VIP
Login
    • Articles
  • Together Against RSVTogether Against RSV
  • SG60SG60
  • PregnancyPregnancy
  • ParentingParenting
  • ChildChild
  • Feeding & NutritionFeeding & Nutrition
  • EducationEducation
  • LifestyleLifestyle
  • EventsEvents
  • Holiday HubHoliday Hub
  • AptamilAptamil
  • TAP RecommendsTAP Recommends
  • ShoppingShopping
  • Press ReleasesPress Releases
  • Project SidekicksProject Sidekicks
  • CommunityCommunity
  • Advertise With UsAdvertise With Us
  • Contact UsContact Us
  • VIPVIP
    • Community
  • Poll
  • Photos
  • Food
  • Recipes
  • Topics
  • Read Articles
    • Tracker
  • Pregnancy Tracker
  • Baby Tracker
    • Rewards
  • RewardsRewards
  • Contests
  • VIP ParentsVIP Parents
    • More
  • Feedback

Privacy PolicyCommunity GuidelinesSitemap HTML

Download our free app

google play store
app store

Grieving mum blames doctor's forceful forceps delivery for newborn's death

6 Jul, 2018
Grieving mum blames doctor's forceful forceps delivery for newborn's death

Even though serious infant injuries after a forceps delivery are extremely rare, sometimes accidents can happen. This is why pregnant mums must be aware of all pros and cons of all delivery methods available to them, and make an informed choice, early.

A recent death of a newborn baby in Long Island USA has sparked more fear towards forceps delivery risks to baby. Tragically, a baby’s head was severed internally from his spine after an obstetrician used a pair of forceps too forcefully.

It all happened when Megan Stirnweiss, 23, was rushed to Southampton Hospital in a last-minute decision after her home delivery had proved to be too painful, in December 2017.

When Dr Pedro Segarra came in with a pair of forceps, Megan’s mum wanted to know if there were any forceps delivery risks to baby. The 60-year-old obstetrician promptly told them there were none and proceeded to deliver the child.

forceps delivery risks to baby

The grieving mother

Pulled Too Aggressively

According to court papers, after the forceps were put around the baby’s head, Dr Segarra yanked the baby out, even dragging Megan along as she clung desperately to the bars of her hospital bed.

But that was not all. With the forceps still around the baby’s head, the doctor lifted Megan off the bed and shook her vigorously until the baby was born at 2.56am.

There was nothing but silence in the delivery room when Matthew Jacob was born. He was limp and blue. His parents never had the chance to hear him cry.

Megan is still in a lot of pain after the delivery. She suffered disruption, dislocation, tearing and lacerations of her internal organs and structures. And she claims that it will require reconstructive surgery to repair the damages she has suffered.

Megan and her husband kept baby Matthew alive on machines for seven days so that his organs could be donated. They are happy that Matthew is giving others the ultimate gift of life.

While Dr Pedro Segarra refuses to comment on what happened, Megan’s lawyer, said her client only wants “accountability.” The grieving parents simply do not want this to happen to anybody ever again.

forceps delivery risks to baby

RIP, little one.

Forceps Delivery Risks to Baby

According to Mayo Clinic, although rare, there are possible forceps delivery risks to baby which include:

  • Minor facial injuries due to the pressure of the forceps
  • Temporary weakness in the facial muscles (facial palsy)
  • Minor external eye trauma
  • Skull fracture
  • Bleeding within the skull
  • Seizures

Usually, only minor marks may appear on your baby’s face after a forceps delivery. This is normal, and the marks are temporary. 

Your doctor might suggest forceps delivery during the second stage of labour. This is only if labour isn’t progressing despite all efforts to push, or the baby’s safety is on the line. Should the forceps delivery fail, your doctor might perform an emergency C-section to take the baby out safely.

Dr Steven Goldstein, a professor of obstetrics and gynaecology at NYU Langone Medical Center thinks that “this is very sad.” He insists that forceps are still very safe and that this case should not be indicative of the way that forceps can and should be used.

 

Sources: New York Post, Mayo Clinic

Lead and feature picture credits: New York Post

Read also: Baby dies 5 days after forceps delivery left her skull fractured

Partner Stories
A New Era of Early Education Begins as Amber Unveils Singapore’s School of the Future
A New Era of Early Education Begins as Amber Unveils Singapore’s School of the Future
Comfort, Care, and Confidence for New Mums  with PEM Confinement Nannies
Comfort, Care, and Confidence for New Mums with PEM Confinement Nannies
Relax & Recover with PNSG Postnatal Massage
Relax & Recover with PNSG Postnatal Massage
Celebrity Dad Mark Lee Shares the 3 P's of Raising School Going Children - Parenting Tips, PSLE Preparation & Protecting Your Child’s Eyesight!
Celebrity Dad Mark Lee Shares the 3 P's of Raising School Going Children - Parenting Tips, PSLE Preparation & Protecting Your Child’s Eyesight!

Got a parenting concern? Read articles or ask away and get instant answers on our app. Download theAsianparent Community on iOS or Android now!

img
Written by

Rosanna Chio

  • Home
  • /
  • News
  • /
  • Grieving mum blames doctor's forceful forceps delivery for newborn's death
Share:
  • A New Era of Early Education Begins as Amber Unveils Singapore’s School of the Future
    Partner Stories

    A New Era of Early Education Begins as Amber Unveils Singapore’s School of the Future

  • From Discomfort to Relief: Managing Haemorrhoids During and After Pregnancy

    From Discomfort to Relief: Managing Haemorrhoids During and After Pregnancy

  • South Korea’s Classroom Phone Ban: What Singaporean Parents Should Know

    South Korea’s Classroom Phone Ban: What Singaporean Parents Should Know

  • A New Era of Early Education Begins as Amber Unveils Singapore’s School of the Future
    Partner Stories

    A New Era of Early Education Begins as Amber Unveils Singapore’s School of the Future

  • From Discomfort to Relief: Managing Haemorrhoids During and After Pregnancy

    From Discomfort to Relief: Managing Haemorrhoids During and After Pregnancy

  • South Korea’s Classroom Phone Ban: What Singaporean Parents Should Know

    South Korea’s Classroom Phone Ban: What Singaporean Parents Should Know

Feed

Feed

Get tailored articles about parenting, lifestyle, expert opinions right at your fingertips

Poll

Poll

Participate in interesting polls and see what other parents think!

Photos

Photos

Share the photos of loved ones in a safe, secure manner.

Topics

Topics

Join communities to bond with fellow mums and dads.

Tracker

Tracker

Track your pregnancy as well as baby’s development day-by-day!

theAsianparent

Download our free app

Google PlayApp Store

Mums around the world

Singapore flag
Singapore
Thailand flag
Thailand
Indonesia flag
Indonesia
Philippines flag
Philippines
Malaysia flag
Malaysia
Vietnam flag
Vietnam

Partner Brands

Rumah123VIP ParentsMama's ChoiceTAP Awards

© Copyright theAsianparent 2026 . All rights reserved

  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Sitemap HTML
  • Tools
  • Articles
  • Feed
  • Poll

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience. Learn MoreOk, Got it

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience. Learn MoreOk, Got it